Balancing Strategic Partnership and Economic Disputes Amid Geopolitical Shifts
Explore the evolving dynamics of US-India trade relations, with a focus on recent tariff disputes, energy security, and the impact of geopolitical factors, including those of Russia and China. Discover how both nations are navigating economic pressures while maintaining a complex strategic partnership.
 |
| "What to do with BRICS and India?" The US deliberates. |
The central issue in US-India trade relations is the ongoing tension between strategic partnership and contentious trade practices, shaped by economic interests, geopolitics, and historical ties.
Bilateral trade has seen substantial growth over the years, with the US being one of India’s largest trading partners. In recent years, trade has expanded across various sectors, including technology, pharmaceuticals (especially during and after the COVID era), textiles, and agriculture.
Trade Imbalance: Despite growing trade, concerns have been raised about trade imbalances, with the US frequently running a trade deficit with India.
The technology and IT services sector is a cornerstone of US-India trade, with Indian companies providing a significant amount of IT services to US businesses.
 |
| Despite several odds, India surges ahead |
Geopolitical Considerations. The US views India as a key partner in maintaining stability in the Indo-Pacific region, especially in the context of rising Chinese influence. It has formed the QUAD alliance.
Trade Disputes, Tariffs and Contentious Issues. Trade relations have faced challenges, including disputes over tariffs, intellectual property rights, and market access. The recent tariff threats and dealings with Pakistan have added to these tensions.
Overall, US-India trade relations represent a strategic partnership marked by both collaboration and contention. The outcome will hinge on how both countries address immediate trade frictions while striking a balance between long-term geopolitical and economic goals.
In recent years, US officials and other Western governments have expressed concerns about India's economic outlook, prompted by statements from President Donald Trump regarding tariffs and critiques of India's trade policies.
On August 4, 2025, President Trump issued a statement on Truth Social indicating his intention to significantly increase tariffs on India, citing India's purchase and resale of Russian oil and its position on the Ukraine conflict as factors influencing this policy approach.
The Trump administration has indicated that India's acquisition of Russian crude oil has become a point of contention in discussions regarding trade agreements. They have also alleged that India is 'funding' Russia's conflict with Ukraine by purchasing its oil.
This development has introduced new challenges for US-India relations and raised uncertainties regarding the direction of ongoing diplomatic engagement.
India's response to Trump's criticism has been characterized by both diplomatic caution and domestic encouragement. India has refrained from escalating tensions publicly, unlike the US, opting instead for measured responses that emphasize the importance of US-India relations. National Security Adviser Ajit Doval is expected to visit Russia this week, as planned, while Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar is anticipated to travel there in the coming weeks. India pointed out that the US had earlier supported India's purchases of Russian crude oil, viewing them as advantageous for the stability of the global energy market. India is formulating a substantial plan worth Rs 20,000 crore to safeguard exporters.
Despite increasing pressure from the Trump administration and the European Union, India continues to import crude oil from Russia. Over the weekend, multiple tankers delivered millions of barrels of Russian crude to Indian refineries, showing that these closely monitored shipments are proceeding without interruption. A media report states that three Aframax vessels—Achilles, Elyte, and Horae—unloaded over 2.2 million barrels of Russian Urals crude at private Indian refiners Nayara Energy Ltd and Reliance Industries Ltd.
India's response to criticism centers on clear arguments and rationale: the necessity of Russian oil imports, criticism of Western double standards, a commitment to sovereignty and economic security, the importance of historical ties with Russia, and the adoption of domestic measures to offset external economic pressures.
Energy Security: India has stated that its imports of Russian oil are crucial for maintaining energy security, particularly in light of fluctuating global oil prices and supply chain disruptions.
Diverse Sourcing: The Indian government emphasizes the need for a diversified energy portfolio, which includes sourcing oil from various countries, including Russia, to meet its growing energy demands.
2. Criticism of Double Standards
India has criticized Western nations, particularly the US and the EU, for singling it out while they continue substantial trade with Russia, including in energy and other sectors. India notes the EU's significant trade volume with Russia in 2024 and similar purchases, such as the US buying uranium, arguing that this reflects a double standard.
India’s foreign ministry argues that many of the countries criticizing its Russian trade also maintain commercial ties with Russia, underscoring that India’s actions are neither unique nor unjustified.
3. Commitment to Sovereignty and Economic Security
National Interests: India has reaffirmed its commitment to safeguarding its national interests and economic security. The government has indicated that it will take all necessary measures to protect its economic stability amidst external pressures.
Non-Aligned Approach: India maintains a non-aligned stance in international relations, which allows it to engage with multiple countries, including Russia, without being bound by the geopolitical conflicts that may affect trade policies.
4. Historical Ties with Russia
Long-standing Relationship: India has a historical relationship with Russia, dating back to the Cold War era. This partnership has included defense cooperation and economic ties, which India views as crucial for its strategic interests.
Defense and Technology Cooperation: The defense relationship with Russia is significant, with India relying on Russian technology and military supplies. This historical context reinforces India's rationale for continuing trade with Russia.
5. Domestic Measures
- Promoting Local Goods: In light of the tariffs and economic concerns, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has encouraged Indians to buy local products to support the domestic economy and offset potential impacts from reduced global demand.
- Economic Strategies: The Indian government has assessed its trade policies and is exploring ways to bolster its economy in response to external pressures by looking to export its products elsewhere.
This response reveals India’s strategy for protecting its economic security and asserting sovereignty, while seeking a balance between its international relationships and domestic priorities amid US pressure.
The US reaction underscores the need to reconcile its strategic partnership with India against emerging trade and currency tensions, highlighting the broader challenge of managing disputes without undermining long-term cooperation.
Also Read: India Fuelling War Machine
US-India trade relations
#USIndiaRelations #TradePolicy #Tariffs #Geopolitics #EnergySecurity #Diplomacy #Russia #IndoPacific #GlobalTrade
